profile

In The Trenches

The 3+3 Negotiation Framework

Published 7 months ago • 2 min read

Welcome to In the Trenches. It’s great to have thousands of you here. My goal with this newsletter is to be all signal and no noise. To that end, make sure you let me know each week how you liked the content.


If every opening in business is a sale (i.e. recruiting, fundraising, pitching), then every close is a negotiation (i.e. hiring, investment, signed deals). The biggest mistake I see most professionals make when negotiating is focusing on the wrong north star. Amateur negotiators care about winning and defeating the competition. Expert negotiators know “winning” is a fool's errand.

In negotiation, the goal is to first expand the pie to create maximum value and then capture as much as possible. So how do you do that?

Use my 3+3 approach.

The 3+3 has two components: (1) Substance and (2) Process. Substance - unsurprisingly - focuses on core elements in the negotiation (e.g. the price and the terms). Process focus on the "everything else." It's counterintuitive, but most deals are lost because the process drivers are managed too casually / lackadaisically.

The 3+3 has served me incredibly well - the cool part about it is it works in any high stakes situation - I have used it close M&A transactions, lock down strategic partnerships, secure Executive talent and squeeze my way into oversubscribed fundraising rounds. Here's how it works:

***

Substantive

I. Define the outcome spectrum

Explicitly define 3 outcomes: (1) great, (2) acceptable and (3) bad. Then place all 3 outcomes on a spectrum. Ask yourself: What are the probabilities of each outcome? What variables drive these probabilities? How interconnected are the variables? It’s important at the outset to understand the boundary conditions from your perspective.

II. Expand the variable set

While you may have clarity on your variables, that’s only one side of the story. You need to understand the other party’s variables. Ask: What matters to them? Most negotiators fixate solely on price; terms and conditions are more important. Think about: time, leverage, brand, coordination, access, reputation, risk. Don’t assume your priorities match theirs.

III. Break the box

Negotiation is all about thinking outside the box. Most negotiators get stuck when they can’t get alignment on a term. In my experience, it’s possible to get aligned on virtually any term; it shouldn’t be the term you debate, it should be the conditions around the term. Use guardrails (contingencies, performance parameters, commitments) to assist in alignment. You can structure anything.

***

Process

I. Build the relationship

Deals are negotiated by humans, not robots (at least for now). Trust is essential to getting a value-generating deal done. Early in the process, focus on finding common ground. What are your shared interests? Connections? Priorities? The sooner you see each other as teammates instead of adversaries, the higher the likelihood of maximum value creation.

II. Communicate appropriately

How do you like to communicate? Text, email, phone, in person? What about who you’re negotiating with? It sounds trivial, but communication style breaks most deals that otherwise should get done. At the outset of the discussion explicitly ask your counterpart how they would prefer to communicate throughout the process. Doing so will help you avoid snowballs turning into boulders.

III. Accelerate the velocity

Time kills all deals. Why? Because it increases the probability that factors unrelated to the negotiation (e.g. market conditions, shifting business priorities) take center stage. Keep the conversation on track—and move swiftly to avoid unnecessary roadblocks.

***

Remember, negotiation is about creating value, not winning. Like we talked about last week, it's always better to get an individual slice of a watermelon than to eat an entire grape.

Until next week,

Romeen



How did you feel about this week’s post?

In The Trenches

By Romeen Sheth

Bootstrapped my business to $60M, brought in PE and currently in the next leg of the journey. Angel investor in 75+ companies. In this weekly newsletter I break down lessons learned, practical frameworks, tools & tactics to level up in business and life.

Read more from In The Trenches

Welcome to In the Trenches. It’s great to have over 10,000 of you here! My goal with this newsletter is to be all signal and no noise. To that end, make sure you let me know each week how you liked the content. Hello again! I took a break from writing for ~6 months. I'm excited to start getting back into it and reconnecting with many of you - I can't promise that I'll be writing weekly (maybe monthly?), but I can promise that if I enter your inbox, I'll always try to share insights that push...

8 days ago • 2 min read

Welcome to In the Trenches. It’s great to have over 10,000 of you here! My goal with this newsletter is to be all signal and no noise. To that end, make sure you let me know each week how you liked the content. Happy New Year! As the year ended, I took a break from writing for ~6 weeks. I'm excited to get back into it in 2024 and reconnect with many of you - I can't promise that I'll be writing weekly, but I can promise that I enter your inbox, I'll always try to share insights that pushes...

4 months ago • 1 min read

Welcome to In the Trenches. It’s great to have thousands of you here. My goal with this newsletter is to be all signal and no noise. To that end, make sure you let me know each week how you liked the content. I am a firm believer that most people can achieve an order of magnitude more than they believe. Why? Because over the last 15 years, I have seen so many normal people achieve incredible outcomes. It is true that many of these outcomes have had a flavor of luck in them. But luck was only...

6 months ago • 2 min read
Share this post